In the realm of experimental music, where artists push boundaries and challenge conventions, Avery Dart's Lurkers of Languid Waters stands as a peculiar and intriguing creation. This album, a labor of love and environmental advocacy, aims to shed light on the plight of eels, particularly the freshwater anguillid eels, through its unique blend of ambient and black metal. However, as I delved into its depths, I found myself questioning the very essence of its impact and the artist's intentions.
Dart's project is a testament to the power of art in raising awareness. By choosing the eel as his muse, he brings attention to the environmental crisis these creatures face, primarily due to overfishing. The album's proceeds support the Nature's Anguillid Eel Specialist Group, a noble cause that deserves all the support it can get. Yet, the execution leaves much to be desired.
The album's opening track, "Eel Black Market," sets the tone for the rest of the record. It's a microcosm of the album's struggles, with shifting guitar tones and vocals that range from tolerable to unlistenable. The grating riffs and 'dirty' vocals create an uncomfortable listening experience, almost as if Dart is intentionally making the listener squirm. This approach, while perhaps effective in grabbing attention, falls short in terms of musical coherence and enjoyment.
As the album progresses, it undergoes a transformation, particularly after the hour mark. The hooks catch hold, and the music becomes more engaging. The synths and trems create an uplifting mood, especially in the track "Journey to the Sargasso Sea." This section is a refreshing change from the initial meandering and dense sound, offering a glimmer of hope amidst the chaos. However, it's a bit too long, and the progressive structure, while engaging, doesn't quite make up for the initial discomfort.
Dart's use of experimental elements, such as bell chimes and mosquito-like buzzing, adds an intriguing layer to the album. These sections, however, feel more like random noise than musical choices. They are intriguing but lack the coherence and purpose that would elevate the overall listening experience.
The album's rating of 1.5/5.0 reflects the mixed feelings I had while listening. While it successfully raises awareness about the eel's plight, the music itself is a chore to endure. The initial shock value may attract listeners, but the intolerable nature of the music will likely drive them away. I found myself appreciating the cause but struggling to appreciate the art.
In my opinion, Dart's project is a missed opportunity. The potential for a compelling and engaging album was there, but the execution fell short. The album's impact is limited by its own discomforting nature, and the listener's willingness to endure it. Perhaps, with a more balanced approach, Dart could have created a masterpiece that not only raises awareness but also captivates and inspires. As it stands, Lurkers of Languid Waters is a thought-provoking but challenging listen, leaving me with a sense of admiration for the cause but a longing for a more accessible and enjoyable musical experience.
